Are we on our way to becoming a cashless society?
As we have discussed in previous blog posts, digital payment
options are increasing exponentially and as such, people are paying with cash
much less often. It is much more
convenient when you can simply pay with a swipe of a card or a few clicks on a
computer or smart phone.
Take a moment and think about the purchases you made this
week. How many of those purchases were
made with cash? If you did use cash, did
you have an option to use some form of digital payment? You can use plastic or an online account to
pay for almost anything these days. Even
vending machines now take credit/debit cards for payment. As we have been working on this project I have been
convinced that we are well on our way to saying goodbye to cash.
Then, I started researching for this particular blog
post.
It seems as though the answer isn’t as clear as I thought.
There
are many articles with headlines indicating that we are quickly on the way to
becoming cashless, but once you read more closely, most agree that it will never
happen, at least not completely. For example, Christopher Mims states “The problem
with all of the arguments for a cashless society is that they’re rational, and
our attachment to cash is not.” (1)
Even a study conducted by Mastercard concludes that we are
quite a way away from becoming totally cashless. While the value of cashless transactions is
higher, the number of actual cash transactions outnumbers those without cash,
as depicted in the graph below. (2)
One reason there is constant hype and headlines convincing
us that this is coming is because banks and financial institutions will win big
if we were to become cashless. Fees from
debit card transactions and the high profitability of credit cards are a big
income boost for them. Also, government
would benefit from a cashless society because of the cost associated with
printing, storing, moving and guarding actual cash. (3)
For the average consumer though, there is a higher personal
cost of ditching cash. Psychological
research clearly shows that when we spend actual cash, we spend more
sensibly. Of all the possible forms of
payment, cash is the one that actually causes us to be mindful of what we are
spending. It is more transparent and
connects us to the fact that we are parting with our money. (4)
It is still too early to make a prediction of where this
will lead, but it appears that, for our own sake, cash will be around for some
time to come. That’s not to say it will
never disappear. If you had told me 10
years ago that my phone would serve as a wallet, calendar, camera, video
recorder, alarm clock, and all the other things I use it for, I would have
laughed in your face. Now I sometimes
think my smart phone is actually laughing at me.
(1) Mims, Christopher. "Why We'll Never Get a Cashless
Society." MIT Technology Review. MIT Technology Review, 28 Feb.
2012. Web. 29 Oct. 2013. <http://www.technologyreview.com/view/427088/why-well-never-get-a-cashless-society/
(2) Mims, Christopher. "We Are so Far Away from the
Cashless Society, Reveals New Study from Mastercard." Quartz. N.p.,
27 Sept. 2013. Web. 29 Oct. 2013.
<http://qz.com/128891/we-are-so-far-away-from-the-cashless-society-reveals-new-study-from-mastercard/>.
(3) Jones, Alex. "A Cashless Society May Be Closer Than
Most People Would Ever Dare To Imagine." Infowars A Cashless Society
May Be Closer Than Most People Would Ever Dare To Imagine Comments. Free
Speech Systems, LLC Company, 30 Mar. 2012. Web. 29 Oct. 2013.
<http://www.infowars.com/a-cashless-society-may-be-closer-than-most-people-would-ever-dare-to-imagine/>.
(4) Burkeman, Oliver. "The Cashless Society Is Coming.
More Reason than Ever to Use Cash." Web log post. The Guardian.
Guardian News and Media Limited, 27 Sept. 2013. Web. 29 Oct. 2013.
<http://www.theguardian.com/news/oliver-burkeman-s-blog/2013/sep/27/cashless-society-spend-money-clinkle>.